Influence of sodium alginate on the formation of the structure of the products from chopped and minced meat

Anna Vasyukova; Marina Kononenko; Alexander Moshkin; Maxim Vasyukov; Anatoly Kushnarenko; Olga Binkovskaya

doi:10.1051/bioconf/20213001023

All issues

Volume 30 (2021)

BIO Web Conf., 30 (2021) 01023

Full HTML

Open Access

Issue		BIO Web Conf. Volume 30, 2021 II International Symposium “Innovations in Life Sciences” (ILS 2020)


Article Number		01023
Number of page(s)		5
Section		Innovations in Food Industry Technology
DOI		https://doi.org/10.1051/bioconf/20213001023
Published online		22 April 2021

BIO Web of Conferences 30, 01023 (2021)

Influence of sodium alginate on the formation of the structure of the products from chopped and minced meat

Anna Vasyukova¹^*, Marina Kononenko¹, Alexander Moshkin¹, Maxim Vasyukov¹, Anatoly Kushnarenko¹ and Olga Binkovskaya²

¹ K.G. Razumovsky Moscow State University of Technologies and Management (the First Cossack University), 1090004 Moscow, Russia
² Belgorod State National Research University, P Sciences, Food Technology Department, 308015 Belgorod, Russia

^* Corresponding author: vasyukova-at@yandex.ru

Abstract

The paper presents the results of using algae as a natural additive to chopped semi-finished meat products. The optimal ratio is set by means of the design method and the results of organoleptic assessment. The mathematical models that help to determine the optimal values of the factors and C, W and T (concentration of the components, moisture content and duration of mincing) are obtained.

© The Authors, published by EDP Sciences, 2021

This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

1 Introduction

Nowadays the growth of the market of products, enriched with amino acids, vitamins, mineral and pectin substances, food fibers, is fixed in Russia.

The development of the products of new generation that meet the requirements of the healthy nutrition, is the main objective in the food industry and the food service. Hippocrates, at his time, stated about the importance of healthy nutrition for disease prevention [1]. The restructuring of the nutrition of the Russian people aimed at providing the sufficient amount of protein is one of the main tasks promoting the optimization of the program on healthy nutrition and longevity of the population. To transfer to the use of the intense methods in the modern food technology, at present time non-traditional protein raw materials, food fibers and polysaccharides for functional food products are used [3, 5].

The level of protein shortage in food products of animal origin contribute to the study of the scientific works concerning the development of the technology of new kinds of meat products that contain both meat and plant protein-rich components [1, 5, 6].

Seaweeds (Laminaria and Fucus) have been the only industrial source of alginate, widely used in the food industry and other spheres. Emulsifying properties of alginates specify their usage in the production of dairy products. The addition of the alginates to the dairy products increases their stability and expiration date. The use of alginate in the production of ice-cream has increased, as it makes the product with soft consistency and even texture, it minimizes the process of crystallization and efficiently extends the expiration date [5, 7, 8].

The main providers of the essential amino acids are proteins of meat, fish, eggs, milk and beans [1, 4]. To get the nutritional proteins from the plant raw materials is the fastest and efficient way in the production of the mixed meat products with unlimited potential properties, which can compensate the scarcity of animal proteins, polysaccharides and a number of mineral substances [1, 4, 9-11].

Therefore, the technology of combining the animal and plant components is considered to be promising in the development of the food industry [12].

The analysis of the literary data shows that the use of Laminaria and Fucus, containing the alginate substances, is steadily developing [13, 14]. Alginate is added to yogurt that improves and keeps its structure and consistency. In this case polysaccharide can be added into the milk during its preparation or after milk coagulation. Alginates are widely used as additives that bind water, prevent from weeping of protein compounds and contribute to getting minced meat (fish or meat) of certain consistency [13-18]. To prevent raw minced fish meat from weeping while thawing the concentration of alginates do not exceed 0.1-0.5%, as a rule [5, 19].

While preparing paste-like fish products, minced fish is subjected to double thermal processing. First, in order to prevent component separation and weeping, minced meat is subjected to thermal processing, and then flavor additives are added. The obtained product is homogenized, packed and sterilized for the second time, due to this its biological value is decreased. The concentration of alginate in the products received can be 0.5-2.0 % depending on the product consistency [5, 15].

Alginates are useful as additives, they improve water-retaining ability, elasticity and stability when minced fish and meat are stored and processed thermally. One of the main tasks the researchers face while developing food and therapeutic products, is to give them a specific form and structure during the process of production. Getting the stable systems with desired composition and properties is a complex task, that is why alongside the formation, granulation and pelletization it is recommended to use stabilizers – substances that change the product consistency [5, 16, 17].

The significance of the research is to examine the development of new meat products using algae as a plant additive.

The aim of the paper is to study the use of algae in the formulas of chopped and minced meat products

2 Experimental

To achieve the set goals other formulas in the given sphere have been analyzed, in order to determine the optimal ratio of the plant additives while setting the experiment.

According to the methods developed for making the experiments in the laboratory of MSUTM named after

K.G. Razumovsky, there has been made an experimental manufacture of chopped semi-finished products using the raw materials such as minced meat (beef, pork, mutton, chicken and duck), algae (laminarium), salt, spices and onion.

The formulas of meat products from chopped and minced meat have been developed with the help of the scheduling method [20, 21].

As soon as the formation of semi-finished products with different variations of paste-like concentrates of algae and meat was finished, the trade analysis was made; according to its results the samples, claimed as the best ones, were subjected to further tests in terms of storage and expiration date of the product. At the certain stages of storage of the samples such parameters as microbiological, physical and chemical and organoleptic were studied according to SanPiN 2.3.2.1078-01.

3 Result and discussion

To determine the option of using algae in the production of chopped semi-finished products from meat (beef, pork, mutton, chicken, duck) there was made a sampling of binary systems with different concentrates of algae and meat components.

The next stage was to develop combined minced meat using minced meat and plant concentrates according to the developed experimental methods.

Based on the pilot tests on determining the optimal formulas and technological modes of minced meat binary compositions combining algae and meat raw materials, the most important factors and the levels of their variations were determined and presented in Table 1.

Sensory analysis of the samples of minced meat combinations with algae was made in the laboratory of Moscow State University of Technologies and Management named after K.G. Razumovsky. The samples of the products were encoded using random three-digit numbers. The results of the sample assessment of each tester were entered into the tasting list. The arithmetic mean of single parameters was calculated and fixed in the tasting lists (Table 2). On the basis of general assessment of the values of complex and single parameters there was drawn a conclusion about the product quality.

Table 3 shows the planning matrix of three stage experiment and the results of organoleptic assessment of the following binary compositions:

$- y 1 - b e e f + a l g a e; - y 2 - p o r k + a l g a e; - y 3 - m u t t o n + a l g a e; - y 4 - c h i c k e n + a l g a e; - y 5 - d u c k + a l g a e$ ${\rm{ - }}y1 - beef {\rm{ + }} algae; {\rm{ - }}\,y2 - pork {\rm{ + }} algae; {\rm{ - }}\,y3 - mutton {\rm{ + }} algae; {\rm{ - }}\,y4 - chicken {\rm{ + }} algae; {\rm{ - }}\,y5 - duck {\rm{ + }} algae$

On the basis of the obtained results the regression analysis of dependences y_i = f(x₁, x₂, x₃) was made and the mathematical models of organoleptic assessment of minced binary compositions was set in relation to the amount of protein product (algae), moisture content in the minced binary compositions and duration of their mincing.

The encoded mathematical models of organoleptic parameters of minced binary compositions are presented as the following equations

$Y_{1} = 28,372 + 0,519 X_{1} - 0,583 X_{2} - 0,634 X_{3} - 1,252 X_{1}^{2} - 0,947 X_{2}^{2}$ ${Y_1}{\rm{ = }} 28,372 {\rm{ + }} 0,519{X_1}\,{\rm{ - }} 0,583{X_2}\,{\rm{ - }} 0,634{X_3}\, - 1,252X_1^2\, - 0,947X_2^2$ (1)

$Y_{2} = 28.133 + 0.528 X_{1} - 0,739 X_{2} + 0,43 X_{3} + 0,425 X_{1} X_{2} + 0,575 X_{2} X_{3} - 0,69 X_{1}^{2} - 0.588 X_{^{2}}^{2}$ ${Y_2}{\rm{ = }} 28.133 {\rm{ + }} 0.528{X_1} - 0,739{X_2}{\rm{ + }} 0,43{X_3}{\rm{ + }} 0,425{X_1}{X_2}{\rm{ + }} 0,575{X_2}{X_3}\,- 0,69X_1^2\,- 0.588X_{^2}^2$ (2)

$Y_{3} = 28.34 + 0,559 X_{2} - 0.666 X_{2} + 0,659 X_{3} - 0.555 X_{3} X_{2} + 0,8 X_{2} X_{3} - 1,567 X_{12} - 0,551 X_{22}$ ${Y_3}{\rm{ = }} 28.34 {\rm{ + }} 0,559{X_2}{\rm{ - }} 0.666{X_2}{\rm{ + }} 0,659{X_3} - 0.555{X_3}{X_2}{\rm{ + }} 0,8{X_2}{X_3}\, - 1,567{X_{12}}\, - 0,551{X_{22}}$ (3)

$Y_{4} = 28.043 - 0,759 X_{1} + 0,792 X_{2} + 1,115 X_{3} + 0,375 X_{2} X_{3} - 1,168 X_{12} - 0,862 X_{22} - 0,456 X_{32} .$ ${Y_4}{\rm{ = }}28.043{\rm{ - }}0,759{X_1}{\rm{ + }}0,792{X_2}{\rm{ + }}1,115{X_3} + {\rm{ }}0,375{X_2}{X_3}\,{\rm{ - }}1,168{X_{12}}\,{\rm{ - }}0,862{X_{22}}\,{\rm{ - }}0,456{X_{32}}.$ (4)

The modified mathematical models of organoleptic parameters of minced binary compositions are presented as follows:

$N_{1} = 19.619 + 0,2137 C + 0,1602 W + 0,0053 T - 0,0031 C_{2} - 0.0024 W_{2}$ ${N_1}{\rm{ = }} 19.619 {\rm{ + }} 0,2137C {\rm{ + }} 0,1602W {\rm{ + }}\,0,0053T - 0,0031{C_2}\,- 0.0024{W_2}$ (5)

$N_{2} = 29.07 + 0,0874 C - 0,0662 W - 0.006 T + 0,0011 C W + 0.0002 W T - 0.0017 C_{2} - 0.0014 W_{2}$ ${N_2}{\rm{ = }} 29.07 {\rm{ + }} 0,0874C\, - 0,0662W - 0.006T {\rm{ + }} 0,0011CW {\rm{ + }} 0.0002WT {\rm{ - }} 0.0017{C_2}\,{\rm{ - }} 0.0014{W_2}$ (6)

$N_{3} = 25.218 + 0.318 C - 0.048 W - 0.0078 T - 0.0014 C W + 0.0003 W T - 0.0039 C_{2} - 0.0014 W_{2}$ ${N_3}{\rm{ = }} 25.218 {\rm{ + }} 0.318C - 0.048W - 0.0078T - 0.0014CW + 0.0003WT - 0.0039{C_2}\,- 0.0014{W_2}$ (7)

$N_{4} = 29.59 + 0.2968 C - 0.1565 C_{2} + 0.1011 T - 0.0045 C_{2} + 0.0017 W_{2} - 0.0001 T_{2}$ ${N_4}{\rm{ = }} 29.59 {\rm{ + }} 0.2968C - 0.1565{C_2}{\rm{ + }} 0.1011T - 0.0045{C_2}{\rm{ + }} 0.0017{W_2}\, - 0.0001{T_2}$ (8)

$N_{5} = 13.263 + 0.1382 C + 0.1330 W + 0.0350 T + 0.0002 C T - 0.0029 C_{2} - 0.0022 W_{2} - 0.00003 T_{2}$ ${N_5}{\rm{ = }} 13.263 + 0.1382C + 0.1330W + 0.0350T + 0.0002CT - 0.0029{C_2}\, - 0.0022{W_2}\, - 0.00003{T_2}$ (9)

Using the methods of mathematical modeling the regression analysis of the mathematical modules Y₁-Y₅ = f (X₁; X₂; X₃) is made.

Table 4 shows the results of the regression analysis

Thus, the results of organoleptic assessment received from the check-lists of the paired comparison showed only the difference in the certain organoleptic parameters of the quality of the minced binary combinations made from meat with various amount of algae. Their organoleptic assessment by means of five-point grading scale allowed not only to assess the level of the quality of minced binary combinations, but to get the mathematical models that help determine the optimal values of the factor and C, W, T (concentration of the components, moisture content and duration of mincing).

This research allows making a conclusion that the optimal values of the factors are:

algae content in minced compositions – 30%
moisture content – 50-60%
duration of mincing – 6 min.

The results of organoleptic assessment of the quality of minced binary compositions made in accordance with the optimal parameters C, W, T (Figure 1) indicate on the different level of the quality of minced compositions form different meat raw materials. It is shown that the range of fluctuations in the assessment of their quality is from 92.6 to 97.6%.

The comparative organoleptic assessment showed the different level of the quality of minced binary compositions, depending on the ration of algae: meat is improving by all the main parameters in the following order: y1, y3, y4, y5, y2.

The best results are obtained in the combination beef + algae and duck + algae with the concentration 30% of algae.

Further, these data are used in the development of the formulas of the functional chopped and minced meat products.

Table 1.

Factors and levels of variation

Table 2.

Organoleptic characteristics of minced combinations based on meat and algae

Table 3.

Planning matrix and results of the experiment

Table 4.

The Results Of The Regression Analysis Of The Mathematical Models

Fig. 1.

Organoleptic assessment of minced binary compositions 1. beef + algae; 2. duck + algae; 3. mutton + algae; 4. chicken + algae; 5. pork + algae

4 Conclusion

The concentrations 10% and 30% of algae as a component of meat and plant system of chopped semi-finished products had no specific flavour and aroma during the tasting assessment. The increase in the content of the plant component up to 50% contributed to the increase in the product output and enhanced algae flavour.

Therefore, it is advisable to study the chopped semi-finished products with 10-30% algae content

References

K.N. Nitsievskaya, O.K. Motovipov, and O.S Grushina, Vestnik of KrasGAU, 208–212, (2011) [Google Scholar]
S.V. Esaulov, Development of chopped meat semi-finished products with calcium animal protein compositions (2009) [Google Scholar]
T.V. Pershakova, T.V. Pershakova, A.T. Vasyukova, T.S. ZHilina, T.V. YAkovleva, V.F. Puchkova, and I.A. Fedorkina, Food Industry, 319, 36–37, (2011) [Google Scholar]
A.T. Vasyukova, I.A. Leonov, V.L. Zaharov, and M.V. Vasyukov, Development and explanation of the technology of grilled semi-finished products (Lambert, Academic Publishing, Saarbrucken, Germany, 2016) [Google Scholar]
V.B. Chmykhalova, Vestnik of Kamchatka State Technical University, 66–78, (2012) [Google Scholar]
K.L. Konovalov, M.T. SHulbaeva, and O.N. Musina, Food Industry, 8, 10–12, (2008) [Google Scholar]
G. Levis, N. Stanley, and G. Guist, Algae and Human Affairs, 206–232, (1988) [Google Scholar]
S.T. Moe, K.I. Draget, and G. Skjak-Brake, Food Polysaccharides and their applications, 245–286, (1995) [Google Scholar]
A.T. Vasyukova and M.V. Vasyukov, International Journal of Innovative Studies in Sciences and Engineering Technology, 3, 15–18, (2017). [Google Scholar]
A. Moshkin, A.T. Vasyukova, and M. Novozhilov, Znanstvena misel journal, 1, 46–52, (2019) [Google Scholar]
B. Kabulov, S. Kassymov, Z. Moldabayeva, M. Rebezov, O. Zinina, Y. Chernyshenko, F. Arduvanova, G. Peshcherov, S. Makarov, and A. Vasyukova, Eurasia J Biosci, 14, 213–218, (2020) [Google Scholar]
M.A. Kolodko, L.A. Zabodalova, and V.N. Krasil’nikov, Low temperature food technologies in the XXIst century, 247–253, (2007) [Google Scholar]
A.T. Vasyukova, V.F. Puchkova, T.S. ZHilina, N.A. Kuharenkova, and I.G. Utarova, Educational medium today and tomorrow, pp. 168–171, (2016) [Google Scholar]
A.T. Vasyukova, A.V. Podkorytova, L.H. Vafina, N.I. Myachikova, and L.V. Dracheva, Fat and Oil Industry, 3, 22–24, (2015) [Google Scholar]
L.Kh. Vaphina, Substantiation of the complex processing of algae (Phaeophyta) while producing functional food products, (2010) [Google Scholar]
D.G. Oakenfuul, CSIRO Food Research Quart, 44, 49–50, (1984) [Google Scholar]
A.A. Slavyanskiy, M.B. Moyseak, V.M. Didenko, and L.S. Petova, Use of food SAW for intensification of technological processes of sugary sector, (2005) [Google Scholar]
E.V. Semenov, A.A. Slavyanskiy, and V.A. Karamzin, Chemical and Oil Machine building, 11, 7–10, (2014) [Google Scholar]
E. Kalakovskiy, Technology of minced fish meat. (Agropromizdat, Moskow, 1991) [Google Scholar]
S.S. Khruschev, A.M. Abaturova, A.N. D’yakonova, D.M. Ustinin, D.V. Zlenko, V.A. Fedorov, I.B. Kovalenko, G.YU. Riznichenko, and A.B. Rubin, Informatics and Modelling, 5, 47–64, (2013) [Google Scholar]
M.A. Nikitina, A.N. Zaharov, V.V. Nasonova, and A.B. Lisicyn, Theory and Practice of Meat Processing, 3, 63–77, (2017) [Google Scholar]

All Tables

Table 1.

Factors and levels of variation

In the text

Table 2.

Organoleptic characteristics of minced combinations based on meat and algae

In the text

Table 3.

Planning matrix and results of the experiment

In the text

Table 4.

The Results Of The Regression Analysis Of The Mathematical Models

In the text

All Figures

	Fig. 1. Organoleptic assessment of minced binary compositions 1. beef + algae; 2. duck + algae; 3. mutton + algae; 4. chicken + algae; 5. pork + algae
In the text

Current usage metrics show cumulative count of Article Views (full-text article views including HTML views, PDF and ePub downloads, according to the available data) and Abstracts Views on Vision4Press platform.

Data correspond to usage on the plateform after 2015. The current usage metrics is available 48-96 hours after online publication and is updated daily on week days.

Initial download of the metrics may take a while.